1. Non-Tender Deadline
With the non-tender deadline approaching, do the Yankees have any obvious candidates?
The most interesting candidate to me is RHP Luis Gil, the 2024 Rookie of the Year winner.
While I didn’t advocate it, I give credit where it is due: some wondered if Gil should be traded at peak value. Gil missed the 2023 season before giving the Yankees a huge 2024 boost, going 15-7 with a 3.50 ERA (4.14 FIP) over 151.2 innings. His 12.1% BB rate was offset by a 26.8% K.
Life hasn’t been good to him since. Between 2025 and 2026, he has pitched only 84.1 innings with a tumbling K rate (15.2%) and a worsening walk rate (13.9%).
Gil is entering his second arbitration year, and salaries don’t go down. MLB Trade Rumors projects him at $2.3M, which isn’t bad even if he were nothing more than an insurance policy. However, Gil might be fried.
Gil is out of options next year. I assume the Yankees are looking for a trade partner (he has tons of team control), but his value has cratered.
Another pitcher the Yankees may be considering is former first-round pick Clarke Schmidt.
Schmidt has been a solid contributor, but the Yankees expected more. In seven MLB seasons, he has thrown only 394 innings, 159 of which were compiled in 2023. His 3.81 ERA (4.04 FIP), 40.7% GB, 23.1% K, and 8.3% BB are league-average-ish. Schmidt is a free agent after the 2027 season, and the Yankees may see if he can win a bullpen/spot starter role. He has the talent for it, but not the health.
The Yankees need relievers, and Fernando Cruz is effective when healthy. Before his 2026 season came to an end due to injury, he owned a 3.13 ERA (4.18 FIP) over 54.2 innings with an impressive 28.6% K. As impressive as that is, it was the first time his K% dipped below 30% in his career. Because his career got off to a late start, he is entering only his second arbitration year despite being 36. I don’t think the Yankees are in a position to cut him loose
2. Brett Gardner makes the Hall of Fame ballot.
Why is this triggering people? Gardner contributed 44.3 bWAR and 37.3 fWAR during his 1,688-game career. He hit .256/.342/.398 and had 274 stolen bases. These are not Hall of Fame numbers. Nobody is claiming they are. However, there are three pieces to the Hall of Fame ballot creation:
- You must play ten seasons;
- The committee determines if your 10+ season career is worth a spot on the ballot (it is NOT automatic)
- The voters choose to agree or disagree with those nominations.
Gardner will not pass the third test. However, I question those who think he doesn’t pass the second test.
I get it that his counting stats don’t stand out. He didn’t score 1,000 runs. He had only 1,470 hits. While his power improved as his career developed, 139 home runs is hardly eye-popping.
However, two other retired players in big league history had exactly 44.3 bWAR: Nomar Garciaparra and Mel Harder. Garciaparra survived his first Hall of Fame vote, garnering just over 5%. He dropped out the next year. Harder, a pitcher, appeared on the ballot 13 times in an era when the 5% threshold didn’t exist.
These three players are vastly different (Garciaparra was a superior offensive player, and Harder was a pitcher), but, like them, Gardner deserves his place on the ballot. I am hard-pressed to find an eligible player with a Gardner-like resume who was left off the ballot.
Gardner is being rewarded for his defensive play. “He won only one Gold Glove!” He likely deserved more, but he played in an era when Alex Gordon hoarded the trophy. It reminds me of when Kent Hrbek couldn’t get past Don Mattingly for the award.
By the way, Gordon was on the 2026 ballot, earning only 0.2% of the vote. Like Gardner, his counting stats didn’t stand out. He made the ballot because of an all-around contribution.
Gardner could garner a few votes from writers who liked him and have open space on their ballot. Given that this is not a strong class of candidates, I can see that happening. No players may be elected this year. Chase Utley will need a big boost to get over the threshold.
But Gardner won’t cross 5%. He won’t come close to crossing 5%.
And that’s OK. He still belongs.