Yankees Notes 11/15

1.  Lou Piniella, Hall of Fame?

Four managers and four executives are on the Contemporary Baseball Era Committee ballot. Three of them (Piniella,  Bill White, and Brian Sabean) have links to the Yankees.

While it isn’t considered, Piniella had a solid MLB career. He hit .291/.333/.409 over 1,747 games (6,362 PA). As a Yankees hitting coach, he is often credited with helping Don Mattingly, who hadn’t shown much power in the minors, adjust his swing to generate more power.

As a manager, Piniella won 1,835 games and a World Series. The championship was in 1990, when the 91-71 Reds knocked off the heavily favored Oakland Athletics, who finished the regular season with 103 victories.

The other managers on the ballot are Bruce Bochy, Joe Maddon, and Dusty Baker.

Bochy is the most likely to make it, given his four championships. That said, he ended his career with an under-.500 record. He is trying to join Connie Mack and Bucky Harris in the “Hall of Famers under .500” club. Mack won five World Series and has the most wins (and losses) in history. Harris has three titles, including one with the Yankees.

Bottom Line:

Piniella was an underrated baseball player and a tad overrated as a manager. That said, he has three World Series rings, a Rookie of the Year Award, and three Manager of the Year awards on his mantel. His body of work is not Hall of Fame worthy, but it is impressive. That said, he missed election by only one vote in 2024.

As for White, his player profile is also impressive (.286/.351/.455; 1,706 hits). He hit over .300 four times, made eight All-Star games, and won seven Gold Gloves. In 2024, he was named on 10 of 16 ballots, falling two short of Hall of Fame induction. He was the National League President from 1989 to 1994 and a Yankees broadcaster from 1971 through 1988. His overall body of work is Hall of Fame-worthy.

2. Yankees re-sign Tim Hill

Hill didn’t have a good 2026 season. He posted a 4.60 ERA (5.93 FIP) over 58.2 innings. Interestingly, he posted the best GB rate of his career (66.8%), but when balls went in the air, they went out of the park (30.8% HR/FB, which is absurd). Between 2025 and 2026, he allowed 20 home runs over 125.2 innings.

Bottom Line:

The contract is reasonable ($2.25M in 2027 + a $2.5M team option in 2028). However, I would have moved on. The Yankees may feel the home run rate will normalize, but he’s always allowed more home runs than you want from a groundball specialist. How crazy is a 30.8% HR/FB rate? My Fangraphs research shows it’s the second-highest in history for pitchers who tossed at least 50 innings in a season, trailing only Dan Otero‘s 31.6% rate from 2018. Like Hill, Otero was a ground ball specialist who gave up too many home runs for his own good.

3. Rule 5 Protection

It’s that time of year! The time when fans start to panic because a team doesn’t protect their favorite A-ball prospect.

Last year, the Yankees protected nobody. Guess how many players they lost during the MLB phase? The answer is nobody. They selected Cade Winquest, kept him on the roster for weeks, then sent him back to the Cardinals without making one appearance. The Cardinals ultimately promoted him late in the season.

Once the Hill signing becomes official, the Yankees will have six open slots on the 40-man roster. This doesn’t mean the Yankees will use those open slots to protect prospects. They had open slots last year too.

RHP Carlos Lagrange is the only prospect guaranteed to earn a spot on the 40-man. Others to watch include OF Jace Avina (the Yankees need outfield depth) and LHP Allen Facundo (the hard-throwing lefty wasn’t protected last year). He didn’t have a great season, but hard-throwing lefties don’t grow on trees. A move to the bullpen should be in the works.

Kyle Carr and Cade Smith are pitching prospects who have lost some of their shine. Luis Serna is not likely to be chosen. The Yankees lack catching depth (understatement), but Omar Alfonzo needs work. Coby Morales is a lefty-hitting corner infielder coming off a .282/.372/.479 (129 wRC+) season for Somerset. He hit 21 doubles and 21 home runs while stealing 21 bases. He is an interesting case, as the Yankees can use the depth. The question is whether he is good enough to play even part-time at third base.

Deeper in the system, Engelth Urena hasn’t done anything to warrant protection.

Now for the prospect that may intrigue some, but not me. No doubt that bonus baby Roderick Arias had a fun campaign. After hitting .271/.357/.441 (109 wRC+) in 93 games for Hudson Valley, he posted a .257/.329/.419 (103 wRC+) in 35 games for Somerset. Overall, he hit 16 home runs while stealing 38 bases. He deserves credit for putting his name back on the map, but he still struck out 30% of the time, and those wRC+ numbers don’t jump out at you. I have no idea what team would both select and keep him for 162 games.

Bottom Line:

Some fans still think about Garrett Whitlock. Get over it. Sometimes, you take a risk with a prospect and lose. Most chosen players end up like Winquest. It’s a fun exercise, but Lagrange is the only player who deserves protection. Maybe a team takes a chance on a prospect like Garrett Martin, who was having a breakout campaign in Scranton before an injury cut his season in half. If healthy, an organization might give him a shot to become their 4th outfielder. I don’t worry about it.

As a final twist:  If the lockout goes long enough, MLB will cancel the Rule 5 draft.

 

 



category : Minor League Reports, Yankees

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Zoomed Image