Thanksgiving Week never seems to disappoint, and 2023 was no different. The Maui Invitational was one of the most loaded fields in recent history, with Purdue emerging from the pack. The Battle 4 Atlantis was a great platform for Villanova to jump from, and Florida Atlantic bounced back strongly from their loss to Bryant to take the ESPN Invitational. UConn continued its streak of double-digit non-conference victories by winning two more to take home the Empire Classic.
Once again, Purdue’s season will come down to their guard play. If this is the year that their guards are able to carry some momentum into the NCAA Tournament, watch out. However, it is tough to get past that they lost to St. Peter’s in 2022 and FDU in 2023.
“Are the tournaments over with?” No. There is one more big tournament (Diamond Head Classic, which starts on 12/21), though it doesn’t feature any currently ranked teams. The Big 5 Classic (the annual games that involve all schools in the Philadelphia area) is finishing up its preliminary games this week, with the championship on Saturday. As it stands right now, Villanova won’t be in that title game. If they beat St. Joseph’s this week, however, the three Pod 2 schools will finish 1-1. I don’t know how they will determine the winner of the pod if that happens. Pod 1 is much easier: Whoever wins the LaSalle-Temple game on Wednesday goes to the championship game.
In case you are wondering why it is called the “Big 5” when there are six schools in the field, this is the first year that Drexel is involved. It is also the first year where they will determine the winner through a championship game. In the past, it was simply best record in a round-robin format.
Top 25:
1. Purdue (6-0) (2) – Gonzaga. Tennessee. Marquette. The Boilermakers ran through a gauntlet to win the Maui and should garner every first-place vote amongst the writers and the coaches.
2. Arizona (6-0) (4) – The Wildcats closed out their November schedule with a win over Michigan State. They own non-conference wins over Duke (road) and Michigan State (neutral) and still have non-conference games remaining with Wisconsin (home), Purdue (neutral, but in Purdue’s home state), Alabama (neutral), and Florida Atlantic (neutral, but in Arizona’s home state). Those four games are consecutive and begin on December 9th.
3. UConn (6-0) (3) – Defeating Texas by ten is considered a close win by the Huskies’ current standards. A road game at Kansas awaits them on Friday night.
4. Marquette (5-1) (5) – Before losing to Purdue in the title game, the Golden Eagles dismantled Kansas by 14 in the semifinals. A well-deserved break comes to an end on Tuesday, when they take on 1-5 Southern. That’s a tune-up for the in-state rivalry game with Wisconsin on Saturday.
5. Kansas (5-1) (1) – The Jayhawks went 2-1 in Maui (one of the wins was over the host Chaminade, but we will excuse that as they beat Kentucky prior to taking a trip over the Pacific). Next is a tune-up game with Eastern Illinois before their big game against UConn.
6. Houston (7-0) (7) – There are 362 Division 1 schools this season, and Houston’s non-conference schedule is currently 257th (KenPom). They won the Charleston title with a win over Dayton and have won every game by double-digits, but their non-conference slate is mostly non-existent and doesn’t get much better (they have a true road game against Xavier and a home game against Texas A&M).
7. Duke (5-1) (8) – The Blue Devil Challenge (a round-robin event against mid-majors) went as expected. The Blue Devils take a trip to Arkansas on Wednesday in the inaugural ACC-SEC Challenge.
8. Miami (5-0) (9) – It’s been over a week since the Hurricanes defeated Kansas State to win the Bahamas Championship. Their break ends with a huge game at Kentucky on Tuesday in the ACC-SEC Challenge. As much as I like this squad, they are currently only 37th in the early season according to KenPom (yes, it is still too early to read much into that)
9. Gonzaga (4-1) (14) – The Bulldogs went 2-1 in Maui, though the way the tournament played out meant games against Purdue-Syracuse-UCLA, allowing them to avoid Kansas, Marquette, and Tennessee. Their remaining non-conference slate includes games against USC, Washington (road), UConn, and San Diego State.
10. Villanova (6-1) (NR) – The loss to Penn stands out, but they made up for that by defeating Texas Tech, North Carolina, and Memphis to take the Battle 4 Atlantis crown. I should have stuck to my guns and kept them ranked even after the Penn loss, but I can’t take that back now. St. Joseph’s, who took Kentucky to overtime and is a local rival, is next on the slate.
11. Creighton (5-1) (6) – The Hall of Fame Classic, where the Blue Jays were heavily favored, didn’t quite go their way as Colorado State destroyed them by 21 points in the title game. Their next two games are true road games against Oklahoma State and in-state rival Nebraska. The Cornhuskers are currently unbeaten (poor schedule, however)
12. North Carolina (5-1) (12) – In one of the best games thus far this season, the Tar Heels lost by two to Villanova in the Battle 4 Atlantis before knocking off Arkansas in the third-place game.
13, Kentucky (5-1) (13) – The Wildcats lost their only difficult game (Kansas by five) to date. They averaged over 100 points per game during the round-robin Wildcat Challenge, though St. Joseph’s took them to overtime. It is hard to get a good read on them – their upcoming games against Miami and North Carolina should provide more clarity.
14. Florida Atlantic (5-1) (19) – There may have been questions about the Owls after their crazy loss to Bryant, but they put those fears to rest by winning the ESPN Events Invitational (wins over Texas A&M and Virginia Tech). Future games against Illinois and Arizona will provide a challenge, but they shouldn’t overlook their next opponent (Liberty).
15. Baylor (6-0) (17) – The NIT Season Tip-Off went the Bears’ way, as they knocked off Oregon State and Florida to take the title. Three of their six victories are over big-name schools (though none are ranked). They still have games with Michigan State and Duke remaining.
16. Texas A&M (6-1) (11) – Considered as the co-favorites to win the ESPN Events Invitational, they lost to Florida Atlantic in the semi-finals. That said, they avenged last year’s NCAA Tournament loss to Penn State and took home third place with their win over Iowa State.
17. Tennessee (4-2) (10) – A top team was destined to lose twice in Maui, and the Volunteers ended up being that team (lost to Purdue by four and Kansas by nine). It doesn’t get easier, as they close out their November with a road game against North Carolina. Their strong defensive play remains their calling card (first in adjusted defense according to KenPom)
18. Colorado State (6-0) (NR) – The Rams didn’t just beat Creighton – they suffocated Creighton. The Mountain West may be San Diego State’s to lose, but Colorado State has placed itself on the list of contenders. An in-state battle with Colorado is coming up on Wednesday.
19. Texas (5-1) (16) – The Longhorns played UConn about as tight as anyone over the last several months, but still came up short by ten. Their upcoming game against Texas State serves as a warm-up heading into their matchup against another Big East power: Marquette in the Big East-Big 12 Battle.
20. BYU (6-0) (NR) – The move to the Big 12 figures to provide the Cougars with a massive challenge. They are tuning up for that challenge in grand fashion by winning the Vegas Showdown (wins over Arizona State and North Carolina State). The rest of their non-conference slate isn’t difficult (a road game against Utah is a roadblock) and they can easily enter Big 12 play with a 13-0 record.
21. James Madison (6-0) (20) – The Cancun Challenge was a battle of mid-majors, and the Dukes took it home with wins over Southern Illinois and Fresno State (a 95-64 demolition). One never knows what will happen in conference play, but this squad at least has a shot to put together a gaudy record (the rest of their non-conference slate isn’t difficult on paper).
22. Mississippi State (6-0) (15) – Obviously, the Bulldogs did nothing wrong and they have an early-season tournament win to fall back on. That said, the schedule is mostly atrocious and other teams jumped over them. The ACC-SEC Challenge doesn’t even give them a big opponent, as they take on Georgia Tech on Tuesday.
23. Alabama (5-1) (21) – The high-flying Crimson Tide (97.8 points per game, tops in the nation) lost to Ohio State by 11 before bouncing back with an 8-point win over Oregon. As mentioned last week, their schedule is one of the toughest in the nation: Unbeaten Clemson in the ACC-SEC Challenge and games against Purdue, Creighton, and Arizona.
24. Memphis (5-1) (18) – The Tigers ran away from Michigan and earned a win over Arkansas before losing to Villanova in the title game of the Battle 4 Atlantis. Their next three games are true road games (Mississippi, VCU, Texas A&M) before a date with Clemson.
25. Illinois (5-1) (25) – Their only quality game is a respectable 7-point loss to Marquette. If they want to truly be the second dog in the Big Ten, they should start with quality performances in their next three games (Rutgers (road), Florida Atlantic, and Tennessee).
Dropped out:
Arkansas (4-3) (22) – The Razorbacks are 1-3 in their last four games (including a loss to UNC Greensboro) with their only win a 3-point triumph over Stanford. They can right the ship with a win over Duke in a home game this week.
Virginia (5-1) (23) – When the Cavaliers have an off-night, it can be ugly. That is what happened in a 65-41 loss to Wisconsin (4-2). The Badgers went on to win the Fort Myers Tip-Off. As for Virginia, Texas A&M is their opponent in the ACC-SEC Challenge.
Liberty (6-0) (24) – I think the Flames are a legit mid-major, but other teams simply surpassed them this week. If they can beat Florida Atlantic on Thursday, the Top 25 will welcome them again.
Just Missed:
Oklahoma (6-0) – The Rady Children’s Invitational was a wide-open affair and it was the Sooners that came through with wins over Iowa and USC to take the championship.
San Diego State (5-1) – Their loss to BYU looks to be more excusable now than it did then (especially since it was a road game). The Aztecs will next play Point Loma Nazarene University (Division II). The Sea Lions went 29-4 last season, winning a pair of games in the Division II Tournament.
Colorado (5-1) – The Buffaloes lost a tough overtime game to Florida State in the Sunshine Slam title game. We’ll see what they do at Colorado State this week as they try to establish themselves as the second-best team behind Arizona in the Pac-12.
Ohio State (5-1) – The Buckeyes have four straight wins after their 7-point loss to Texas A&M. That includes taking out Alabama in the Emerald Coast Classic. It is not easy to differentiate several Big Ten schools at the moment, and this squad is right in the mix.